Island knowledge, national expertise

Performance of Employment Contract 'Tainted by Illegality' - Cautionary Tale

There is nothing wrong with an employee being paid in a tax-efficient manner. As an Employment Tribunal (ET) ruling showed, however, where such arrangements stray into the realms of unlawful evasion the consequences are likely to be severe.

The case concerned a commercial director whose bonuses and profit-related pay were in part remitted not to him but to his wife. Following his resignation, he lodged ET proceedings against the company for which he worked, asserting unfair constructive dismissal and unlawful deductions from his wages.

Ruling on a preliminary issue in the case, the ET found that the purpose of diverting part of his remuneration to his wife was plainly to reduce his tax bills. Whether or not he had proposed the payment arrangements, he plainly had knowledge of them and was an active participant in the scheme. On that basis, the ET found that his performance of his employment contract was tainted by illegality.

In those circumstances, the ET concluded that public policy demanded that his unfair dismissal complaint be struck out, together with his claims in respect of notice pay and unpaid bonus and profit-related remuneration. It found, however, that it would be disproportionate to strike out his claims in respect of unpaid basic salary and holiday pay. Those claims were permitted to proceed to a full hearing.

The ET found that the wife had genuinely carried out administrative support work for the husband and that her employment by the company was not a sham. She had no knowledge of the tax evasion that was occurring, nor had she participated in it. All of their earnings ended up in a single joint account and she simply left everything to be sorted out by her husband. On that basis, her claims of constructive unfair dismissal, unlawful deduction from wages and breach of contract were also allowed to proceed.

  • "Thank you for the wonderful advice your firm gave us. We will have no hesitation in contacting you should we need any help in the future."

    — Client, Isle of Wight

  • "Thank-you again - you really have been amazing and so helpful and I’m extremely grateful."

    — Client

  • "Parisa - Thank you so much for all that you have done for me, your kindness and patience have made my claim so much easier and explaining everything to me has helped so much. Thank you again."

    — Client, Isle of Wight

  • "Thank you for the wonderful advice Claudia gave us. We will have no hesitation in contacting you should we need any help in the future."

    — Client

  • "The service I received was second to none. I will of course happily recommend you to others."

    — Client

  • "Thank you to Parisa, who phoned me this morning. She was absolutely brilliant, provided crystal clear advice and put my mind at rest. For months I've wondered whether or not I should consult a solicitor and I now feel that I can move forward."

    — Client

The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.